copyright Favoring Brave LLC 2023
Some people don't just lead groups — they grow people, walking with the same souls year after year. That's a charism (spiritual gift) of pastoring, and you don't need a collar to have it.
Every charism makes some aspect of God present in the world. Pastoring makes His shepherd's heart present — the patient, personal love of a God who knows His sheep by name and stays with them (John 10:14). The person with this charism does what Jesus did with the Twelve: gathers a particular group of people and walks with them for a long time, forming their faith through relationship rather than programming.
Two words in the definition carry the weight. Community — this gift doesn't just teach individuals; it knits people together into groups where faith grows. And long-term — pastoring isn't the retreat-weekend gift or the one great conversation. It's the small-group leader still shepherding the same families eight years later, the mentor whose people span decades. Depth over reach, always.
The word "pastor" makes everyone think of ordained ministry, so let's clear this up early: pastoring is a charism, not a job title. Many priests have it (and their parishes can tell), but the Holy Spirit gives it across every rank of the faithful (Lumen Gentium 12). The small-group leader people never want to graduate from, the youth minister who's attended a decade of her former teens' weddings, the grandmother whose kitchen table has formed three generations — that's this gift, fully itself, no ordination involved.
If you have it, the Church needs you to use it on purpose: leading a small group, mentoring, walking with OCIA candidates through their first years, building the communities parish life runs on.
The shepherd is one of Scripture's oldest images for this kind of love: "The Lord is my shepherd" (Psalm 23:1), and God's promise to "appoint for you shepherds after my own heart" (Jeremiah 3:15). Jesus claims the image — "I am the good shepherd, and I know mine and mine know me" (John 10:14) — and then explicitly hands the work on: "Feed my lambs... Tend my sheep" (John 21:15–17). St. Paul lists pastors among the gifted people Christ gives the Church "to equip the holy ones for the work of ministry" (Ephesians 4:11–12), and St. Peter charges his readers: "Tend the flock of God in your midst... not lording it over those assigned to you, but be examples to the flock" (1 Peter 5:2–3).
If you're exploring this charism, read one passage a day and notice which ones feel like a description of you.
If you answered yes to any of these, that is a decent indicator that pastoring might be one of your charisms. Discernment still takes prayer, feedback, and testing — but it's a strong starting point.
The charism of pastoring is not responsibility for outcomes that belong to God — and it is not a license to control. A shepherd tends; only God grows (1 Corinthians 3:6–7). People you've poured years into will sometimes wander anyway, and that grief is real, but it isn't a verdict on your gift. The healthy expression of this charism holds people close and holds them freely — St. Peter's "not lording it over" is the boundary line. If you've walked with someone faithfully and they still chose a far country, you're in good company: so did the Father in the parable, and His door stayed open.
The charism assessment gives you an objective, outside read on where the Holy Spirit is most likely at work in you — winnowing the list of 24 possible charisms down to your most likely few in about 20 minutes.
It's the charism that empowers a person to build effective Christian community and enter long-term relationships of Christian formation that elevate the faith of the people they serve — the shepherding gift Jesus modeled with the Twelve and handed on (John 21:15–17; Ephesians 4:11).
Yes. Pastoring is a spiritual gift, not an office — the Holy Spirit distributes charisms among the faithful of every rank (Lumen Gentium 12). Lay small-group leaders, mentors, and community-builders exercise this gift constantly, and parish life depends on them.
Teaching transmits truth that changes people; leadership moves a group toward a vision. Pastoring is distinguished by relationship over time: personal, long-term formation of particular people and the knitting of those people into community. Many pastors (ordained or lay) hold more than one of these gifts, but each is distinct on the assessment.
Start with the charism assessment for an objective read on your most likely charisms, then confirm through prayer, feedback from people who know you well, and testing. The Catechism says this discernment is always necessary (CCC 801).
Ep. 38 — The Charism of Pastoring. The shepherding gift — what it looks like in laypeople, and why depth beats reach.
Listen on Apple Podcasts · Find the show wherever you listen
The Essential Handbook on Living Your Charisms has a full chapter on pastoring — including beginner-to-advanced ways to test the gift and a daily charism prayer.